Eyeliner causing irritated, red eyes

Hey everyone, I'm trying to understand what I'm doing wrong while using eyeliner. I've been noticing that often after using eyeliner - most of which are brand new, I wake up the next morning with extremely red, cloudy, and irritated eyes- this will last at least a full day before clearing up. I notice this more when I'm trying different colors perhaps, like blue especially will mess up my eyes. But recently the same has happened with a brand new Nars brown eyeliner.

I'm taking off my makeup - doing a double-cleanse too, so I just don't understand why this keeps happening :(

Have any of you experienced this? And do you have any suggestions? Appreciate any and all feedback!